- Case Report
- Open Access
Arrhythmogenic right ventricular cardiomyopathy secondary to adipose infiltration as a cause of episodic collapse in a horse
Irish Veterinary Journal volume 68, Article number: 24 (2015)
The Erratum to this article has been published in Irish Veterinary Journal 2017 70:19
A 15-year-old Clydesdale cross gelding was investigated and managed over a 2-year period for intermittent collapse. The horse presented initially after an observed episode of collapse at rest, and had a resting tachycardia, elevated Cardiac Troponin I and polycythaemia. Multiple dysrhythmias were detected on telemetric electrocardiography. Vital parameters, cardiac rhythm and red cell count returned to reference range with prolonged rest but further resting syncopal episodes were observed, and due to safety concerns and limited treatment options the horse was euthanased. Post mortem evaluation identified extensive infiltration and replacement of right and left ventricular myocardial fibres with adipose and fibrous tissue, consistent with arrhythmogenic right ventricular cardiomyopathy. This report provides further information regarding the clinical and pathological features of this rarely reported condition.
Arrhythmogenic right ventricular cardiomyopathy (ARVC) is a primary heart muscle disease well documented in humans and boxer dogs for which 30–50 % of cases may have a familial component [1, 25]. ARVC is characterised morphologically by fibrofatty infiltration of the right ventricle myocardium which leads to conduction abnormalities . In boxer dogs presenting signs include sudden death, ventricular arrhythmias of suspected right ventricular origin, syncope and heart failure . ARVC due to fibrofatty infiltration has been previously reported in two horses as a cause of cardiac death  although a genetic predisposition has not been identified in equids.
Syndromes of collapse are rare in the horse but cardiac disease has been identified as the most common cause with dysrhythmias (3rd degree atrioventricular block, atrial tachycardia with advanced second degree AVB and atrial fibrillation) and cardiac disease (right sided heart failure) reported . Other causes include neurocardiogenic syncope, sleep disorders, seizures, hypoglycaemia, hyperkalaemic periodic paralysis and dysautonomia . The presenting sign in this case was syncopal episodic collapse, with presumed transient losses of consciousness and postural tone due to cerebral hypoperfusion, followed by spontaneous recovery. In this report the presumptive relationship between syncopal episodes, clinically detected cardiac abnormalities and pathological evidence of ARVC in a 15 years old Clydesdale cross gelding is discussed, with further evidence to suggest ARVC as a rare differential diagnosis for episodic collapse in horses.
A 15-year-old Clydesdale cross gelding presented to the Weipers Centre Equine Hospital for further investigation of three observed episodes of collapse in the preceding 9 months with two having occurred in the 6 weeks prior to referral. In the first observed event the horse tilted its head, developed a transient reduction in awareness and dropped saliva from its mouth. The two subsequent episodes were more marked with loss of awareness and partial loss of postural tone requiring the horse to lean against a wall to prevent full collapse (see additional resource for video). All events had occurred at rest, with rapid recovery and with no post-ictal period. Clinical examination after each event had been unremarkable. On the day of the most recent collapsing episode a blood sample was taken and a haematology profile identified a significant polycythaemia (51.1 (reference interval, 31–35) % ) with a mild leukopaenia (4.12 (reference interval, 5.4–14.3) ×109 cells/l) and left shift neutropaenia (2.2 (reference interval, 2.7–6.8) × 109 cells/l). The polycythaemia did not reflect a state of hypovolaemia as total serum protein (71 (reference interval, 60–80) g/l) and renal parameters were not significantly elevated (urea 7.2 (reference interval, < 6.84) mmol/l); creatinine 119 (reference interval, 62–140) μmol/l) on a biochemistry profile. The horse was then referred for further investigation.
At presentation the horse was quiet but alert and in excess body condition (BCS 4/5 ; 681 kg). On auscultation a mild resting tachycardia (48 bpm) was present with no appreciable arrhythmias or murmurs noted. All other vital parameters were within normal limits.
Elevation of haematocrit (47 (reference interval, 31–35) %) was present on a repeat haematology profile. Total serum protein, electrolytes (including total and ionised Ca2+, Mg2+, Na+, Cl− and PO4 3−) and fibrinogen concentrations were within reference range. Cardiac troponin I (CTnI) was markedly elevated (9.82 (reference interval, < 1.3) ng/ml). Blood erythropoietin concentration (5.5, (reference interval, 5.0–10.0) MIU/ml) was within normal limits.
Direct arterial pressure was measured via a catheter in the transverse facial artery. Mean arterial blood pressure was increased (160 mmHg, (reference interval, 80–100) mmHg) with elevation of systolic and diastolic blood pressures (220 and 130 mmHg respectively).
Arterial blood gas analysis was performed prior to, immediately after and 45 min after 15 min of moderate intensity exercise on the lunge. Oxygenation was within normal limits (PaO2 85–95 mmHg) and a mild metabolic acidosis was present immediately after exercise (lactate 3.5, (reference interval <2) mmol/l) that had resolved 45 min later. These findings were considered normal for the fitness of the horse.
A telemetric 24-h Holter ECG (Kruuse, Langeskov Denmark) was performed during the period of hospitalisation. Frequent multiform ventricular premature complexes (VPCs) were noted (Fig. 1) with approximately 10 per hour and several short bursts of spontaneous supraventricular tachycardia (maximum HR 180 bpm) were present when the horse was quiet in the stable, each lasting up to 60 s. Abnormal fluctuations in sinus rhythm were appreciable at lower heart rates. Echocardiographic evaluation was impeded by the excess body condition and size of the horse but no significant abnormalities were noted on the images that were obtained.
The findings of a full neurological examination were unremarkable.
An initial diagnosis was made of myocarditis (of unknown aetiology) with syncopal episodes presumed to be due to a temporary reduction in cardiac output and subsequent hypoxia resulting from dysrhythmia. Differentials for the polycythaemia included chronic hypoxaemia and primary polycythaemia (bone marrow neoplasm).
A period of pasture rest was recommended and due to the excess body condition of the horse dietary recommendations (1.5 % of bodyweight of dry hay, soaked for 12 h with a pelleted feed balancer for micronutrient and protein supplementation) were made both for general health and to facilitate further repeat echocardiography.
The horse was re-examined on three further occasions, the first of which was 2 weeks after original discharge. During this 2-week period no further syncopal episodes had been observed and the demeanour of the horse had improved. The resting heart rate had decreased to within normal limits (36–40 bpm). Repeat bloodwork identified a reduction in packed cell volume (37 %) and CTnI (<0.1 (reference interval, <1.3 ng/ml)) was within normal limits. A repeat 24-h telemetric Holter ECG1 was unremarkable. This improvement in clinical and clinicopathological parameters supported a resolving acute pathology and a further period of rest was recommended.
A second re-examination was performed 4 months later due to another observed collapse that morning. The horse had been brought in from the field and started eating feed, but then had stopped eating and rested its head against the wall of the stable, with a lowered head carriage and had maintained this position for 20–30 min. After this period the horse had regained normal posture and returned to eating. With the exception of the excess condition of the horse (BCS 4/5; 697 kg) the findings of clinical examination and bloodwork (haematology including acute phase proteins, biochemistry, CTn I) were unremarkable. Repeat echocardiography was again limited by the excess body condition but cardiac chamber dimensions were within normal limits. A telemetric Holter ECG1 was placed and a 24-h trace was recorded. The horse was also exercised on the lunge for 10 min at trot and canter. No significant abnormalities were noted.
The final examination was performed just over a year later after a further documented episode of collapse. The horse had been tied up loosely and was eating when it suddenly started to back up with the head raised and subsequently fell down into lateral recumbency. The horse had paddled with the front legs and lip chomped with vacant eyes for approximately 2–3 min, before immediately standing and returning to eating with no suggestion of post-ictal change.
On repeat clinical examination the horse had reduced body condition (BCS 3/5; 613 kg). Vital parameters were within normal limits. Haematology and biochemistry profiles including acute phase proteins and CTnI were all within reference range. Echocardiographic evaluation was again hampered by poor image quality due to the horse’s size, but no abnormalities were noted and measurements taken were within normal limits. A telemetric ECG was placed for 15 h. The majority of the trace was unremarkable with a low resting heart rate (36 bpm), regular rhythm and homogenous morphology of complexes. However, there were multiple short periods of supraventricular tachycardia with no apparent external stimuli as found on previous examination. Ventricular premature complexes were present as previously, but at much reduced frequency (4 VPCs in 15 h).
Due to the intermittent and progressive nature of the syncopal episodes there were significant implications for horse welfare and human safety. Since no treatment options were available the owner elected to have the horse euthanased.
On post mortem examination gross and histological abnormalities were restricted to the cardiac muscle. The epicardium of the right ventricular free wall and the endocardium were infiltrated by a yellowish soft tissue extensively expanding deep into the myocardium obliterating more than 60 % of the myofibers. The left ventricle was similarly affected with 20–30 % of the myofibres destroyed by the infiltration. Small foci of this yellowish tissue were also multifocally observed in both the left and right atria (Fig. 2a–d).
Histopathological examination of the myocardium, epicardium and endocardium revealed similar changes in both ventricles. Cardiomyocytes were markedly reduced in number and replaced by abundant adipose tissue intermixed with variably thickened bundles of fibrous connective tissue. Residual cardiomyocytes within or around the adipose tissue were highly vacuolated with loss of the myofibrils and nuclear detail (degeneration). Interspersed were low numbers of lymphocytes and macrophages. Periodic acid-schiff (PAS) stain highlighted the disruption of Purkinje fibres by the adipose tissue. Masson’s trichrome stain highlighted the variably thickened bundles of fibrous connective tissue dissecting the myofibres (Fig. 3a–c). Frozen sections stained with Oil Red confirmed the large vacuolar infiltrate as adipose tissue. There was no evidence of parasitic infiltration grossly or microscopically. The skeletal and smooth muscle were grossly unremarkable in appearance.
A post mortem diagnosis was made of syncope presumed secondary to myocardial degeneration with extensive, severe, chronic, adipose and fibrous infiltration of the right and left ventricle, consistent with arrhythmogenic right ventricular cardiomyopathy.
Discussion and conclusion
Episodes of collapse are rare in the horse and evidence based literature is limited. The aetiology of the collapse is frequently difficult to establish as it is complicated by the intermittent nature of the clinical signs. In the case series by Lyle et al.  only 44 % of horses had a definite diagnosis. The case reported here was classified as syncopal due to the progression of clinical signs to loss of postural tone and full loss of consciousness together with post mortem findings. Differential diagnosis for syncopal collapse can be broadly divided in to cardiac, neurally mediated and miscellaneous causes (volume depletion, endotoxaemia, drugs, dysautonomia) .
The abnormalities noted on sequential examinations in this horse pointed to an ante-mortem diagnosis of cardiac pathology. The original presentation with a resting tachycardia, polycythaemia, increased CTnI, frequent VPCs, and intermittent bursts of supraventricular tachycardia was temporally associated with one of the syncopal episodes. Elevated CTnI is a sensitive and specific biomarker of myocardial damage . Boxer dogs with confirmed ARVC had a significantly higher serum CTnI concentration than non-Boxer controls  with values correlated to increasing numbers of VPCs per 24 h and grade of ventricular arrhythmia. In horses myocardial disease, structural heart disease and arrhythmias have been reported to cause elevations in CTnI . In this case CTnI was elevated only on first presentation and normalised over 2 weeks, consistent with a discrete insult  or more likely in this case, an acute on chronic insult.
Polycythaemia was determined to be absolute (i.e. not secondary to splenic contraction or hypovolaemia) and appropriate due to the repeatability of the abnormality, absence of concurrent markers of hypovolaemia and lack of post mortem renal or neoplastic changes . At the time of sampling the erythropoietin assay was within normal limits (which would support a primary erythrocytosis from bone marrow proliferation) but the half life of erythropoietin is only 5 h . Given the post mortem findings, polycythaemia secondary to chronic hypoxaemia seems more probable. The rapid improvement in red cell count and resting heart rate soon after first evaluation suggest that tissue hypoxaemia was improving at this time.
The relationship between the cardiac pathology noted at post mortem and the syncopal episodes is presumptive but given the cardiac abnormalities on initial examination and absence of other abnormalities on further diagnostics or at post mortem examination, the combined evidence of cardiac syncope is compelling. To form a more definitive ante-mortem diagnosis it would have been beneficial to leave the Holter ECG in place for a longer period in combination with video monitoring when the horse was hospitalised. An implantable cardiac monitor (ICM, ECG recording device) would have allowed longer term monitoring , using either a remote, observer operated trigger, or automatic dysrhythmia induced recording.
Fibrofatty infiltration of the cardiac muscle in the horse is not reported as an incidental post mortem finding in reports evaluating a racehorse population , working horses [10–12] or a general population . A comparable abattoir study of non athletic or obese horses has not been recorded. Adipose and fibrous tissue infiltration of the myocardium has been documented previously as a cause of cardiac death in two horses . One of these horses presented with ventricular tachycardia that was refractory to medical management and progressed to ventricular fibrillation and death; the second horse was found dead in the field. Both animals had significant adipose and fibrous infiltration of the right ventricle wall and interventricular septum wall with disruption of the Purkinje fibres, similar to this case, and a diagnosis of arrhythmogenic right ventricular cardiomyopathy was made. Unlike this case, the horses reported by Freel et al.  both had an enlarged right ventricle, but this may reflect the end progression of the disease, given that both of those cases had suffered fatal cardiogenic collapse. The parallels between these changes and pathologies noted in humans and dogs have been discussed at length previously  but it is notable that syncopal episodes are common (52 %) in Boxer dogs with ARVC . Left ventricular pathology which was also noted in this case is observed in a small proportion of affected boxer dogs  but greater than 50 % of affected humans  with no specific identified risk factors.
This case provides additional evidence of the adverse impact of adipose and fibrous infiltration on cardiac function in the horse and the implications of Purkinje fibre disruption for transmission of electrical activity within the cardiac muscle. Purkinje fibre disruption in the ventricles is associated with the development of ventricular dysrhythmias and sudden death in humans .
Clinical manifestations of ARVC in humans relate to development of ventricular tachycardia or ventricular fibrillation and it is a rare but important cause of sudden death in young people, particularly athletes. There is a known genetic susceptibility in 30–50 % of cases . A similar proportion of Boxer dogs have evidence of familial susceptibility with autosomal dominant inheritance suspected . This horse was a 15 year old Clydesdale cross Cob type. The previous report documented a 5 year old Clydesdale and a 15 year old Cob. Further documentation of this rare condition would be required to establish if there is any breed susceptibility.
The excess body condition of the horse may also be pertinent to the development of the cardiac pathology. In humans the relationship between obesity, a pro-inflammatory state, metabolic syndrome and cardiac pathology is well documented and similar infiltrative changes in the myocardium are reported in obese humans  as noted in this horesistance seen in Equine Metabolic syndromerse. Increased pericardial adipose tissue deposition is associated with an increased risk of cardiovascular disease, hypothesised to be due to a paracrine effect [8, 18]. It is unknown whether myocardial adipose tissue would have a similar effect in the horse. Endocrine testing was not performed in this horse but obesity is correlated to insulin resistance seen in Equine Metabolic syndrome . Obesity is common in horses in the UK [23, 27] without development of similar clinical signs but in humans cardiovascular disease is multifactorial and the same may be true within the equine population.
In conclusion adipose and fibrous tissue infiltration of the cardiac muscle should be added to the differential diagnosis list as a rare but significant cause of cardiac arrhythmia and syncope when investigating horses for intermittent collapse. This syndrome is potentially comparable to that of arrhythmogenic right ventricular cardiomyopathy noted in boxers and humans and requires further investigation.
Arrhythmogenic Right Ventricular Cardiomyopathy
Cardiac Troponin I
Ventricular Premature Complex
Basso C, Fox PR, Meurs KM, Towbin JA, Spier AW, Calabrese F, et al. Arrhythmogenic right ventricular cardiomyopathy causing sudden cardiac death in boxer dogs. A new animal model of human disease. Circulation. 2004;109:1180–5.
Basso C, Corrado D, Marcus FI, Nava A, Thiene G. Arrhythmogenic right ventricular cardiomyopathy. Lancet. 2009;373:1289–300.
Baumwart RD, Orvalho J, Meurs KM. Evaluation of serum cardiac troponin I concentration in Boxers with arrhythmogenic right ventricular cardiomyopathy. AJVR. 2007;68(5):524–8.
Belli CB, Baccarin RY, Ida KK, Fernandes WR. Appropriate secondary absolute erythrocytosis in a horse. Vet Rec. 2011;169:609.
Buergelt CD. Equine cardiovascular pathology: an overview. Anim Health Res Rev. 2003;4(2):109–29.
Carroll CL, Huntington PJ. Body condition scoring and weight estimation of horses. Equine Vet J. 1988;20:41–5.
Chien KR. Genomic circuits and the integrative biology of cardiac diseases. Nature. 2000;407:227–32.
Ding J, Hsu FC, Harris TB, Liu Y, Kritchevsky SB, Szklo M. The association of pericardial fat with incident coronary heart disease: the Multi-Ethnic Study of Atherosclerosis (MESA). Am J Clin Nutr. 2009;90:499–504.
Elliott S, Pham E, Macdougall IC. Erythropoietins: a common mechanism of action. Exp Haematol. 2008;36:1573–84.
Else RW, Holmes JR. Cardiac pathology in the horse I gross pathology. Equine Vet J. 1972;4:1–9.
Else RW, Holmes JR. Cardiac pathology in the horse II microscopic pathology. Equine Vet J. 1972;4:57–62.
Else RW, Holmes JR. Cardiac pathology in the horse III clinical correlations. Equine Vet J. 1972;4:195–203.
Freel KM, Morrison LR, Thompson H, Else RW. Arrhythmogenic right ventricular cardiomyopathy as a cause of unexpected cardiac death in two horses. Vet Rec. 2010;166:718–21.
Kraus MS, Jesty SA, Gelzer AR, Ducharme NG, Mohammed HO, Mitchell LM, et al. Measurement of plasma cardiac troponin I concentration by use of a point-of-care analyzer in clinically normal horses and horses with experimentally induced cardiac disease. Am J Vet Res. 2010;71:55–9.
Lyle CH, Keen J. Episodic collapse in the horse. Equine Vet Educ. 2010;22:576–86.
Lyle CH, Turley G, Blissitt KJ, Pirie RS, Mayhew IG, Mcgorum BC, et al. Retrospective evaluation of episodic collapse in the horse in a referred population: 25 cases (1995–2009). J Vet Intern Med. 2010;24(6):1498–502.
Lyle CH, Uzal F, McGorum BC, Aida H, Blissitt KJ, Case JT. Sudden death in racing Thoroughbred horses: an international multicentre study of post mortem findings. Equine Vet J. 2011;43:324–31.
Mahabadi AA, Massaro JM, Rosito GA, Levy D, Murabito JM, Wolf PA, et al. Association of pericardial fat, intrathoracic fat, and visceral abdominal fat with cardiovascular disease burden: the Framingham Heart Study. Eur Heart J. 2009;30:850–6.
Marcilese NA, Valsecchi RM, Figueiras HD, Camberos HR, Varela JE. Normal blood volumes in the horse. Am J Physiol. 1964;207:223–7.
Meurs KM. Boxer dog cardiomyopathy: an update. Vet Clin North Am Small Anim Pract. 2004;34:51235–44.
Nath LC, Anderson GA, Hinchcliff KW, Savage CJ. Serum cardiac troponin I concentrations in horses with cardiac disease. Aust Vet J. 2012;90:351–7.
Schwarzwald CC, Hardy J, Buccellato M. High cardiac troponin I serum concentration in a horse with multiform ventricular tachycardia and myocardial necrosis. J Vet Intern Med. 2003;17:364–8.
Stephenson HM, Green MJ, Freeman SL. Prevalence of obesity in a population of horses in the UK. Vet Rec. 2011;168:131.
Szczepaniak LS, Victor RG, Orci L, Unger RH. Forgotten but not gone: the rediscovery of fatty heart, the most common unrecognized disease in America. Circ Res. 2007;101:759–67.
Taylor GP. The pathology of arrhythmogenic right ventricular cardiomyopathy congenital diseases in the right heart. In:Redington AN, van Arsdell G, Anderson RH, editors. Springer-Verlag London Limited; 2009. p.125–129.
Vick MM, Adams AA, Murphy BA, Sessions DR, Horohov DW, Cook RF, et al. Relationships among inflammatory cytokines, obesity, and insulin sensitivity in the horse. J Anim Sci. 2007;85:1144–55.
Wyse CA, McNie KA, Tannahill VJ, Murray JK, Love S. Prevalence of obesity in riding horses in Scotland. Vet Rec. 2008;162:590–1.
The authors would like to thank Alistair McInnes, Mike Cathcart, Marco Duz and Richard Irvine for their involvement with this case.
The authors declare that they have no competing interests.
DS was the senior clinician dealing with the case assisted by AR. AR drafted the manuscript and DS edited the manuscript. HT and NCG performed the post mortem, evaluated the histopathology and drafted the pathology section of the manuscript. All authors read and approved the final manuscript.
An erratum to this article is available at http://dx.doi.org/10.1186/s13620-017-0099-4.