- Case report
- Open Access
Partial avulsion of the ulnaris lateralis and enthesiopathy of the lateral epicondyle of the humerus in a thoroughbred race horse
Irish Veterinary Journal volume 71, Article number: 10 (2018)
There is relatively little literature on elbow disease in the horse. The only published reports on soft tissue conditions describe collateral ligament and biceps brachii injuries.
A three-year old Thoroughbred gelding presented with a history of acute onset right forelimb lameness of less than one week duration, one month after commencing training in a National Hunt racing yard. Physical examination and peri-neural anaesthesia failed to localise the lesion. Lameness was localised to the distal humerus by nuclear scintigraphy and intra-articular anaesthesia. A partial avulsion of the tendinous origin of the ulnaris lateralis and enthesiopathy of the lateral humeral epicondyle was diagnosed on ultrasonography. Ultrasonographic findings were loss of longitudinal fibre pattern, a discrete hypo-echoic region within the ulnaris lateralis tendon of origin, and remodelling of the lateral epicondyle of the right humerus at the site of the origin of the ulnaris lateralis. No abnormalities were identified on radiography. The lameness did not resolve with rest, but was successfully treated with extra corporal shockwave therapy (ECSWT) and intra-lesional corticosteroid injections.
This is the first report of partial avulsion of the ulnaris lateralis and enthesiopathy of the lateral humeral epicondyle in the horse. In contrast to other reported soft tissue conditions of the elbow, this horse had a successful return to work. This case highlights the value of ultrasonography in assessing peri-articular soft tissues, and the importance of pain relief as treatment in some soft tissue injuries.
Lameness originating from the elbow joint in horses is relatively uncommon, and there is currently limited evidence on diseases affecting the soft tissues of the elbow in the horse. Although there are reports of lateral collateral ligament injury , radial enthesiopathy of the elbow  and avulsion fracture of the ulnaris lateralis (personal communication ) in horses, avulsion of the ulnaris lateralis origin and enthesiopathy of the lateral epicondyle have not been reported. This case report describes the clinical presentation, diagnosis, treatment and successful outcome of a three-year old thoroughbred gelding with acute onset partial avulsion of the tendinous origin of the ulnaris lateralis, and enthesiopathy of the lateral epicondyle of the humerus.
A three-year old Thoroughbred gelding presented with a history of acute onset right forelimb lameness of less than 1 week duration, 1 month after commencing training in a National Hunt racing yard. The horse was not yet in fast work. The trainer reported that he had been difficult to break in, but there had been no specific traumatic incident.
On presentation the gelding was 3/5 lame on the right fore in trot in a straight line . On physical examination there were no focal sites of pain or swelling detected, a flexion test and extension test were negative on both forelimbs. An abaxial-sesamoid nerve block did not improve the lameness. The trainer elected not to investigate further at this time.
Following a period of 2 weeks box rest, the gelding re-presented at the hospital for further evaluation. There was no change in the clinical findings. The lameness was not altered by the following nerve blocks; palmar digital, abaxial-sesamoid, low 4-point, high 4-point and deep branch of the lateral palmar nerve. Intra synovial anaesthesia of the antebrachio-carpal and mid-carpal joints also did not alter the lameness. Medio-lateral and cranio-caudal radiographs of the shoulder and elbow joints were unremarkable. The trainer elected not to investigate further at this time.
Following a period of 6 weeks box rest there was no change in the lameness. There was atrophy of the right fore shoulder muscles, but no abnormalities or localising signs on physical examination. The horse was represented to the hospital for further investigation.
Nuclear scintigraphy was performed: 7.5GBq of 99 m technetium-hydroxymethane diphosphonate (99mTc-HDP) was administered into the jugular vein. Images were obtained with a low-energy, general all-purpose collimatorFootnote 1 2 hours after injection. There was focal increased radiopharmaceutical uptake in the region of the right fore distal humerus (Fig. 1a and b) Due to the absence of a cranial craniocaudal scintigraphic view, this could not be localized further on the basis of the scintigraphic findings.
Palpation, and focal pressure applied to the lateral epicondyle did not elicit a reproducible pain response from the horse. Flexion and extension tests were still unremarkable.
Intra-articular anaesthesia of the cubital joint was performed, 25 ml of mepivicaineFootnote 2 was injected into the joint at the site of the palpable depression between the cranial aspect of the olecranon and the caudal aspect of the lateral epicondyle of the humerus. After 5 minutes the lameness was improved, and the horse was sound after 15 min.
Ultrasound examination of the left and right elbow joints, were performed using a 10mHz linear transducer.Footnote 3 Transverse and longitudinal views of the lateral aspect of the elbow showed an irregular bone surface and remodelling of the lateral epicondyle of the right humerus at the site of the origin of the ulnaris lateralis tendon . The fibre pattern of the ulnaris lateralis tendon was disrupted on the longitudinal view, with a discrete hypo-echoic region at the site of origin onto the lateral epicondyle (Fig. 4). A reference ultrasound image (obtained from a different 3yo thoroughbred horse) of the ulnaris lateralis origin on the lateral epicondyle is shown in fig. 5a and b, in addition a reference image of the origin of the collateral ligament of the elbow is shown in Fig. 5c.
The presence of bone modelling and the ultrasonographic changes within the ulnaris lateralis tendon were considered to be consistent with a diagnosis of a partial avulsion of the origin of the ulnaris lateralis and enthesiopathy of the lateral epicondyle of the humerus.
Following discussion with the owner, a period of paddock rest was undertaken, after 6 weeks the gelding was improved to 1/5 lame.
A further five-month period of paddock rest was undertaken.
At re-presentation there was no further change in the clinical signs (1/5 lame), or ultrasonographic findings. Following aseptic preparation, the ulnaris lateralis tendon of origin was injected with 10 mg of triamcinalone (Adcortyl), the lateral epicondyle of the humerus was then treated with extracorporal shock wave therapyFootnote 4 at 3.0 Bar with a 15 mm transmitter for 3000 pulses. The trainer reported that he was sound 3 days later and he was started in work. The lameness recurred after 6 weeks, the same treatments were repeated, and 3 days later the horse was sound and able to resume work. A third treatment was carried out 5 weeks later, although the horse remained sound and the shoulder muscle atrophy had resolved.
There was no recurrence of the lameness. There have been no further instances of lameness in the subsequent 18 months, and the horse has raced with no further related issues.
Discussion and conclusions
Lameness attributable to the elbow region is relatively uncommon in the horse. Soft tissue injuries to the collateral ligament and enthesiopathy of the biceps brachii tendon have been described [1, 2], but avulsion of the ulnaris lateralis and remodeling of the lateral epicondyle of the humerus, have not. There is a single description of avulsion of the ulnaris lateralis, as a personal communication , of a case with radiographic changes.
The diagnosis in this case was based on increased radionucleotide uptake in the region of the humeral epicondyle, a positive response to local anaesthesia of the elbow joint and ultrasonographic findings of bone remodelling and changes in the ulnaris lateralis tendon.
The elbow is a large joint therefore radiography in the horse is not sensitive to focal subtle changes. It is possible that further radiographic projections would have revealed the new bone formation identified ultrasonographically.
Intra-articular analgesia of the elbow joint significantly improved the lameness in this case, despite the lesion being extra-articular. It is most likely that the local anaesthetic diffuses out of the volumous caudoproximal joint space to eliminate pain from the lateral epicondyle. Had local anaesthesia been performed earlier in the investigation, imaging of the elbow region would have been indicated and the diagnosis could have been reached without the cost of scintigraphy. However, as this condition has not been previously reported, scintigraphy was valuable in ruling out more common injuries with similar presentation, such as stress fractures or other bony abnormalities, and in identifying the distal epicondyle of the humerus as the site of pathology.
ECSWT has been shown to be beneficial in providing pain relief for insertional tendinopathies and desmopathies in man [4, 6] and is widely used in the horse. The usual frequency of treatment in man is once weekly; in this case the interval was 6 weeks; therefore the corticosteroid injection may have contributed more significantly to the duration of pain relief. However it is also possible that the condition was self-limiting and would have resolved spontaneously when training was resumed.
In man lateral elbow tendinopathy (LET) is a common condition causing pain on the lateral aspect of the distal humerus. Although there are similarities with this case, the soft tissue structures affected differ; it is caused by a stressed common extensor origin lateral epicondyle complex of the effected elbow . In cases of LET the diagnosis is primarily based on the patient’s description of the problem, focal pain, the results of physical examination and exacerbation tests, such as gripping tests. The most common imaging modalities for confirming the diagnosis in LET are ultrasonography and MRI , Nuclear scintigraphy has also been reported to be valuable . Ultrasonography is considered a reliable imaging technique for LET , findings are similar to this case with hypoechogenicity of the soft tissues involved and bone changes of the lateral epicondyle [5, 7]. There are many conservative treatments proposed for LET including ECST [4, 6]. Corticosteroid injections are thought to be useful in the acute stage but potentially detrimental in the chronic stage , as chronic LET appears to have no inflammatory component . There are several surgical options for treatment of recalcitrant cases of LET, these are variously supported by reported evidence, they include denervation of the lateral humeral epicondyle  and percutaneous release under local anaesthesia . In man, the tendinous origins at the lateral epicondyle are accessible arthroscopically from the elbow joint, subequently the most recently described surgical options are arthroscopic release techniques .
The case described did not resolve with rest and free exercise for a total of over 6 months. The combination of intra-lesional corticosteroids and extra corporal shockwave therapy (ECSWT) were used to provide pain relief and facilitate a return to exercise. This resulted in strengthening of the shoulder muscles as observed by the resolution of shoulder muscle atrophy. It is most likely that the improved muscle strength was able to compensate for the injured structure and thus resolve the lameness. Given the response to intra-articular analgesia, arthroscopic evaluation of the elbow joint could have been considered an option in this case. The diagnosis was based on increased radionucleotide uptake in the region of the humeral epicondyle on scintigraphy and the ultrasonographic findings of bone remodelling and changes in the ulnaris lateralis tendon.
Partial avulsion of the ulnaris lateralis and enthesiopathy of the lateral epicondyle of the humerus should be considered as a differential diagnosis for horses presenting with acute onset forelimb lameness, with no localising signs, that does not block to the distal limb, or resolve with short-term periods of rest. In contrast to other reported soft tissue injuries in the elbow, this horse successfully returned to exercise beyond his previous level. This case highlights the value of ultrasonography in assessing peri-articular soft tissues, and the importance of pain relief to facilitate exercise and allow strengthening of muscles to compensate for some cases of soft tissue injury.
General Electric, Bartec Medical Imaging Systems, Camberley, Surrey, England.
Intra-Epicaine® 20 mg/ml, Dechra Veterinary Products, Shrewsbury, England.
LogiqS7 Expert, BCF Technology, Strathclyde Business park, Scotland.
Masterpuls®, MP200Vet, Storz medical, 8274 Tägerwilen, Switzerland
Extra coporal shockwave therapy
Lateral elbow tendinopathy
Magnetic resonance imaging
Oikawa M, Narama I. Enthesopathy of the radial tuberosity in two thoroughbred racehorses. J Comp Pathol. 1998;118(2):135–43.
Dyson SJ. Chapter 40. The elbow, brachium and shoulder. In: Ross MW, Dyson SJ, editors. Diagnosis and and Management of Lameness in the horse. 2nd ed. Missouri: Elsevier Saunders.
Swanson TD. Guide for veterinary service and judging of equestrian events. 3rd ed. Golden: American Association of Equine Practitioners; 1984.
Carayannopoulos A, Borg-Stein J, Sokolof J, Meleger A, Rosenberg D. Prolotherapy versus corticosteroid injections for the treatment of lateral epicondylosis: a randomized controlled trial. PM R. 2011;3(8):706–15.
Latham SK, Smith TO. The diagnostic test accuracy of ultrasound for the detection of lateral epicondylitis: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Orthop Traumatol Surg Res. 2014;100(3):281–6.
Sayegh ET, Strauch RJ. Does nonsurgical treatment improve longitudinal outcomes of lateral epicondylitis over no treatment? A meta-analysis Clin Orthop Relat Res. 2015;473(3):1093–107.
Hoy G, Wood T, Phillips N, Connell D, Hughes DC. When physiology becomes pathology: the role of magnetic resonance imaging in evaluating bone marrow oedema in the humerus in elite tennis players with an upper limb pain syndrome. Br J Sports Med. 2006;40(8):710–3. discussion 713
Lizis P. Analgesic effect of extracorporeal shock wave therapy versus ultrasound therapy in chronic tennis elbow. J Phys Ther Sci. 2015;27(8):2563–7.
Behrens SB, Deren ME, Matson AP, Bruce B, Green A. A review of modern management of lateral epicondylitis. Phys Sportsmed. 2012;40(2):34–40.
Pitzer ME, Seidenberg PH, Bader DA. Elbow tendinopathy. Med Clin North Am. 2014;98(4):833–49.
Rose NE, Forman SK, Dellon AL. Denervation of the lateral humeral epicondyle for treatment of chronic lateral epicondylitis. J Hand Surg Am. 2013;38(2):344–9.
Nazar M, Lipscombe S, Morapudi S, Tuvo G, Kebrle R, Marlow W, Waseem M. Percutaneous tennis elbow release under local anaesthesia. Open Orthop J. 2012;6:129–3.
Savoie FH, Van Sice W, O'Brien MJ. Arthroscopic tennis elbow release. Shoulder Elbow Surg. 2010;19(2 Suppl):31–6.
The staff of Oakham veterinary hospital, Prof. Sarah Freeman and Prof. Gary Enland.
No funding was available for this study.
Availability of data and materials
Data sharing not applicable to this article as no datasets were generated or analysed during the current study.
Ethics approval and consent to participate
This case report has been approved by the ethics committee of Nottingham University Vet School.
Consent for publication
I hereby give consent for publication.
The author declares that he has no competing interests.
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.